Skip to main content

PACE · 10 min read · 2026-07-01 · Updated

Advising Clients on the Caution and Silence at the Police Station

Trainees who recite the caution but never check the client understood it give unsafe advice. This article quotes the caution from Code C, explains each part in plain language, and sets out what the law says about no comment interviews, prepared statements and significant statements, without slogans.

Police station representative explaining the police caution and silence options

Breaking down the caution in plain English

Code C paragraph 10.5 sets the wording of the caution: “You do not have to say anything. But it may harm your defence if you do not mention when questioned something which you later rely on in Court. Anything you do say may be given in evidence.” It has three parts, and each needs its own explanation. Clients often hear only the first sentence and miss the rest.

Code C Note 10D says: “If it appears a person does not understand the caution, the person giving it should explain it in their own words.” You should check understanding in the same way in consultation. Use short sentences: “You can choose not to answer. If you stay quiet now but later rely on something important you didn’t mention, a court might be asked to consider why. Anything you do say can be used as evidence.” Adjust the vocabulary for juveniles and vulnerable adults, with the appropriate adult present where Code C requires it.

Never suggest the caution is a trick or that the police already know the client is guilty. A steady tone helps the client make a considered decision.

What the law says about silence

The second sentence of the caution reflects section 34 of the Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 1994. Where the accused, on being questioned under caution, “failed to mention any fact relied on in his defence” which “in the circumstances existing at the time the accused could reasonably have been expected to mention”, the court or jury “may draw such inferences from the failure as appear proper”. Section 38(3) adds that a person shall not “have a case to answer or be convicted of an offence solely on an inference drawn from such a failure”.

The Crown Court Compendium (Part I, section 17-1, paragraph 5) says: “The statutory right to draw inferences is aimed at the failure to mention facts on which reliance is placed at trial, not mere silence itself.” See Adverse inference: advising on interview for the legal advice condition in s.34(2A).

Silence strategies: no comment and prepared statements

A no comment interview is a lawful choice for the client. Whether it is the right advice depends on the disclosure, the strength of the evidence and the client’s instructions, weighed against the risk of an inference. Explain it to the client as a considered strategy and record the reasons for your advice.

A prepared statement puts a controlled account on record while the client declines to answer further questions. The Compendium (section 17-1, paragraph 6) states: “If a prepared statement is submitted by or on behalf of D in lieu of answers to questions posed in interview, no inference is available unless D later relies on facts which do not appear in the prepared statement.” The same paragraph adds that “There is no requirement that the unmentioned fact must be one about which the accused has specifically been asked a question”. So the statement needs careful drafting, and the client must approve it.

Partial answers (answering on some topics only) need clear instructions and careful advice about inference risk on the topics left unanswered. Seek supervision until you are confident with these.

Significant statements and interview conduct

Clients may have said things before you arrived: on arrest, at the cell door or to custody staff. Code C 11.4 requires the interviewer, at the start of the interview and after cautioning, to “put to them any significant statement or silence which occurred in the presence and hearing of a police officer or other police staff before the start of the interview”. Code C 11.4A defines a significant statement as “one which appears capable of being used in evidence against the suspect, in particular a direct admission of guilt.” So ask the client in consultation what was said, to whom, and whether it was written down.

During the interview you can intervene. Code C Note 6D says the solicitor “may intervene in order to seek clarification, challenge an improper question to their client or the manner in which it is put, advise their client not to reply to particular questions, or if they wish to give their client further legal advice.” Under paragraph 6.9 a solicitor may only be required to leave “if their conduct is such that the interviewer is unable properly to put questions to the suspect.”

After the interview, consider whether the advice still holds if new disclosure arrives before a charging decision. Advice can change with new information and instructions; record any change and why.

Exam preparation and professional limits

Revise the caution together with adverse inference and disclosure before interview. The PSR Train question bank links these topics.

Know when to pause and ask your supervising solicitor about complex silence strategies, for example with co-suspects or serious indictable allegations.

Sources

All sources were opened and checked on 30 October 2026. Quotations are taken word for word from the paragraph or subsection cited.

Important note

This is general training information for police station representatives and PSRAS candidates in England and Wales. It isn’t legal advice on any individual case. Last reviewed 30 October 2026.