Skip to main content

CIT · 11 min read · 2026-06-27 · Updated

How to Pass the Critical Incidents Test (CIT)

CIT failure is usually visible method, not missing statute — trainees jump to no comment before they list Code C issues. I teach a four-step framework (Issues, Disclosure, Consultation, Decision) and the spoken client sentences assessors need to hear.

Candidate working through a structured method for the PSRAS Critical Incidents Test

What the CIT really assesses

The Critical Incidents Test (CIT) is one of the three PSRAS accreditation assessments, alongside the written examination and the portfolio. The SRA assessment guidelines (paragraph 7.1) say its purpose is to assess “a candidate’s effectiveness in advising and assisting a client at the police station by reference to the Standards of Competence”. Under paragraph 7.4, it “may only be taken after a candidate has registered with the LAA as a probationary representative”.

It is not a written scenario you talk through at your own pace. Paragraph 7.2 describes it as “a role-play test consisting of several issues or problems posed to the candidate, either verbally or in terms of their behaviour, by a police officer, client or third party”. A recording signals when you must respond, and “The candidate then has 30 seconds in which to commence a response.” If you don’t start within 30 seconds, you lose the chance to respond to that issue. The Cardiff University PSRAS course page describes the test as one that “uses audio recordings to provide information” and says “The whole of the test is recorded for assessment purposes.” The SRA guidelines (paragraph 7.3) require the assessment organisation to “record on audiotape the entire test procedure in respect of each candidate”.

Your answers are marked on three criteria. Paragraph 8.1 lists Control, Confidence and Content, with Content covering “the legal, procedural and factual content of the candidate’s response, including whether they have analysed the facts correctly and whether they have applied the law to those facts correctly”. Under paragraph 8.2 each criterion has equal weight and “To pass, a candidate must achieve at least 50 per cent in respect of each criterion.” Paragraph 8.3 then says, in full: “Assessment regulations must state that a gross professional error, committed in the context of the assessment, must lead to a candidate failing the CIT even though their numerical score equals or exceeds the pass mark. It is the responsibility of the Assessment Board to decide what constitutes a gross professional error.” So a good score does not save a serious mistake, and the guidelines leave it to your assessment organisation's Assessment Board to decide what counts as one.

That is why memorising alone fails. A candidate can know Code C well and still stumble if they cannot respond quickly, keep control of the situation and give advice in plain language. There is rarely a single “right” answer to each issue, but there is always a safe, structured way to reach a defensible response.

A four-step framework for practice

For revision, use a simple framework: Issues, Disclosure, Consultation, Decision. Issues: what Code C points does this situation raise, such as the basis for detention, time limits, vulnerability and appropriate-adult triggers, or fitness to interview? Disclosure: what do you actually know, and what is missing? Thin disclosure shapes everything that follows.

Consultation: what advice follows from the disclosure and the client’s instructions, including how you would explain the caution, silence and adverse inference in plain language? Decision: what position do you take (answer questions, no comment, or a prepared statement), and why? The strength of an answer lies in the reasoning that connects the disclosure and instructions to the decision, not in the decision label itself.

In the real test you won’t have time to narrate four steps for every issue. Each issue arrives as a prompt from an officer, the client or a third party, and you have 30 seconds to start responding. Practise the framework until it runs automatically in your head, so that your spoken response goes straight to the point: what you would say or do, to whom, and why.

Common mistakes that cost marks

A frequent error is advising no comment as a reflex. No comment can be the correct advice, but stating it without linking it to inadequate disclosure, weak identification or the client’s instructions, and without explaining inference risk, sounds like a slogan rather than reasoning. Show the path that leads to the decision.

A second group of mistakes involves welfare and disclosure: ignoring vulnerability and appropriate-adult triggers, failing to ask for missing disclosure, or giving advice that does not match the client’s instructions. The test is recorded, so if you never say what you would request, the assessor cannot assume you would have asked.

Watch for weak control and over-claiming. Control and Confidence are marked separately from Content, so a hesitant or theatrical response can lose marks even when the law is right. Advising definitively when the facts make your advice provisional is also risky. Acknowledge uncertainty honestly (“my advice may change when the promised CCTV summary arrives”) and you show the judgement the test is looking for.

Five habits to coach out before the test

  • Advising before you have worked out the issue. Use the first seconds of each prompt to decide what is urgent, what may be unlawful and what affects the client's welfare, then respond to that.
  • Missing vulnerability triggers. Listen for age, signs of mental ill health or learning disability, language needs and an absent or unsuitable appropriate adult. If the information is unclear, say what you would ask the custody officer. The test for vulnerability is suspicion, not proof. Code C paragraph 1.4 says: “If at any time an officer has any reason to suspect that a person of any age may be vulnerable (see paragraph 1.13(d)), in the absence of clear evidence to dispel that suspicion, that person shall be treated as such”. Age works the same way. Code C paragraph 1.5 says: “Anyone who appears to be under 18, shall, in the absence of clear evidence that they are older, be treated as a juvenile for the purposes of this Code and any other Code.” PACE s.37(15) uses the same test: an “arrested juvenile” is a person “who appears to be under the age of 18”.
  • Quoting PACE without advising the client. After each legal point, add the plain sentence you would actually say to the client.
  • Side issues before consultation. Secure private consultation and challenge an unlawful interview plan before you raise secondary points such as bail conditions. The right is to private advice: PACE s.58(1) says a detained person “shall be entitled, if he so requests, to consult a solicitor privately at any time”, and Code C paragraph 6.1 says detainees must be told they “may at any time consult and communicate privately with a solicitor”. If an officer wants to start the interview first, Code C paragraph 6.6 says: “A detainee who wants legal advice may not be interviewed or continue to be interviewed until they have received such advice unless” one of the listed exceptions applies, such as a delay authorised under Annex B.
  • Forgetting the firm. Say when you would update your firm or seek your supervising solicitor's input, for example on a conflict of interest, a serious disclosure failure or an ethical limit on your advice.

Practice tips that build CIT performance

Practise out loud and against the clock. Reading a scenario and thinking “I would probably go no comment” is not practice. Have a colleague play the officer or the client, give you short prompts, and time you: can you begin a clear, relevant response within 30 seconds? Record yourself, then listen back for jumps in reasoning and unclear sentences to the client.

Draw scenarios from your weakest knowledge areas so practice does double duty. If detention reviews are shaky, run a scenario with time-limit pressure; if identification is weak, build one around a disputed street identification. Pair one scenario each week with your timed question drills for balanced preparation.

Rehearse the spoken language of representation, not just the legal conclusions. Practise explaining the caution, adverse inference, and the difference between silence and guilt in calm, plain sentences a stressed client could follow, and practise firm but polite representations to an officer.

Managing time under the 30-second rule

Because you have 30 seconds to begin each response, time management in the CIT is about starting well, not writing fast. A useful default order for your mental triage is: the client's welfare and access to consultation; any unlawful procedure or Code C breach; gaps in identification or disclosure; interview strategy, once the basics are safe; and the update to your firm.

Lead with your top priority so the most important point is on the recording early, then add your reasons. Speed comes from recognising recurring Code C patterns, not from rushing. In the final two months before your sitting, one or two timed scenarios a week alongside your question practice is a sensible routine.

Bringing it together on assessment day

Listen carefully to each prompt and respond to the issue actually raised. Start your response promptly, then give your reasons. A clear, ordered answer is easier to follow and assess on the recording.

Keep your responses defensible rather than dramatic. State your position, give the reasons drawn from disclosure and instructions, and say what would cause your advice to change. This is the same proactive, documented judgement that good portfolio attendances show, so the two kinds of preparation reinforce each other.

This is general training information for PSRAS candidates in England and Wales. It doesn’t replace your firm’s supervision or your assessment organisation’s materials. Confirm the current CIT format and assessment regulations with your assessment organisation before you sit.

Sources

All sources were opened and checked on 1 November 2026. Quotations are taken word for word from the paragraph or section cited.

Important note

This is general training information for police station representatives and PSRAS candidates in England and Wales. It isn’t legal advice on any individual case. Assessment figures (time limits, pass marks and question weightings) are correct as of 1 November 2026; always check the current rules with the SRA and your assessment organisation before you sit. Last reviewed 1 November 2026.